Best Wine Clubs | PickGuides

Scores and product facts reflect the dated comparison snapshot. See how we rank.

Sort by:

Best Overall
1Wine Insiders
9.9 / 10Reference score
- types: Award-winning red and white wines, international classics, popular varietals, and hidden gems
- subscription-options: Make a one time purchase or 12 bottles delivered quarterly
- shipping: Free shipping on 6+ bottles
- guarantee: Our Perfect Pour Promise: 100% money‑back guarantee, cancel anytime
Official site Compare
2Swirl Wine Shop
9.7 / 10Reference score
- types: Red, white, and mixed
- subscription-options: No subscription required, order bottles as you want them
- shipping: Free shipping
- guarantee: 100% satisfaction guarantee - if you don't like it, get store credit
Official site Compare
3Firstleaf
9.5 / 10Reference score
- types: Award-winning domestic and international wines including red, white, rose, and sparkling
- subscription-options: 6 or 14 bottles every 2-12 weeks
- shipping: Free shipping on the first order
- guarantee: 100% satisfaction guarantee
Official site Compare
Best Monthly Club
4Amazing Clubs
9.4 / 10Reference score
- types: Red, white, or mixed
- subscription-options: 2 or 4 full-sized bottles every month for 3 months, 6 months, 12 months or quarterly
- shipping: Free shipping in the continental US
- guarantee: "They'll Love It" Guarantee
Official site Compare
5Winc
9.1 / 10Reference score
- types: Red, white, rosé, and mixed
- subscription-options: 6 bottles every month or 12 bottles every 12 weeks
- shipping: Free shipping for 4+ bottles
- guarantee: Bottle replacement for any wines you dislike
Official site Compare
6Naked Wines
8.8 / 10Reference score
- types: Reds, whites, rosés, and sparkling
- subscription-options: Unlimited bottle shipments
- shipping: Free shipping on orders of $200 or more
- guarantee: Get a refund for any bottle you don't like
Official site Compare
7Bev
8.5 / 10Reference score
- types: Red, white, rosé, sparkling, and variety packs
- subscription-options: Bev Club subscription or one-time purchase
- shipping: Free 2-day shipping on every order
- guarantee: Low-calorie and 0% sugar in every can
Official site Compare
8Wine Access
8.4 / 10Reference score
- types: All reds or mixed shipments
- subscription-options: 2, 4, or 6 bottles per shipment or one-time purchase
- shipping: Free shipping on orders over $150
- guarantee: Get credit toward your next order for any bottles you don't like
Official site Compare
9wine.com
8.2 / 10Reference score
- types: Red, white, champagne, sparkling
- subscription-options: 3, 6, or 12 months
- shipping: Free shipping
- guarantee: 100% satisfaction guarantee
Official site Compare
10Wine by Lamborghini
7.9 / 10Reference score
- types: Red, white, sparkling
- subscription-options: Annual
- shipping: Free standard shipping on all domestic US orders. No minimums.
- guarantee: Not available
Official site Compare

Our Top Choice

Best Overall

1Wine Insiders

9.9 / 10Reference score

types: Award-winning red and white wines, international classics, popular varietals, and hidden gems
subscription-options: Make a one time purchase or 12 bottles delivered quarterly
shipping: Free shipping on 6+ bottles
guarantee: Our Perfect Pour Promise: 100% money‑back guarantee, cancel anytime

Official site Compare

Compare Features

Service	Best Overall—. Wine InsidersWine Insidersofficial destination requires review	—. Swirl Wine ShopSwirl Wine Shopofficial destination requires review	—. FirstleafFirstleafofficial destination requires review	Best Monthly Club—. Amazing ClubsAmazing Clubsofficial destination requires review	—. WincWincofficial destination requires review
types	Award-winning red and white wines, international classics, popular varietals, and hidden gems	Red, white, and mixed	Award-winning domestic and international wines including red, white, rose, and sparkling	Red, white, or mixed	Red, white, rosé, and mixed
subscription-options	Make a one time purchase or 12 bottles delivered quarterly	No subscription required, order bottles as you want them	6 or 14 bottles every 2-12 weeks	2 or 4 full-sized bottles every month for 3 months, 6 months, 12 months or quarterly	6 bottles every month or 12 bottles every 12 weeks
shipping	Free shipping on 6+ bottles	Free shipping	Free shipping on the first order	Free shipping in the continental US	Free shipping for 4+ bottles
guarantee	Our Perfect Pour Promise: 100% money‑back guarantee, cancel anytime	100% satisfaction guarantee - if you don't like it, get store credit	100% satisfaction guarantee	"They'll Love It" Guarantee	Bottle replacement for any wines you dislike

HOW WE RANK

PickGuides preserves dated product facts, reference scores and reviewed destinations in each published version. Authorized comparison pages may use documented automatic checks; commercial relationships do not replace factual validation.